| ATHLETE | SPORT |
| Adams, Aimee | Softball 1st Team 1991 |
| Adams, Jenni | Softball 1st Team 1992; Softball 1st Team 1993 |
| Adams, Nolan | Baseball 1st Team 2017 |
| Adams, Todd | Baseball 1st Team 1994 |
| Adams, Wendy | Basketball 2nd Team 1995; Softball 1st Team 1993; Softball 1st Team 1994; Softball 1st Team 1995; Softball 1st Team 1996 |
| Atherton, Jarret | Football 1st Team 2017 |
| Baldwin, Baylee | Softball 1st Team 2018; Softball 1st Team 2019 |
| Ballert, David | Baseball 1st Team 1988 |
| Barron, Ashleigh | Softball 1st Team 2006; Softball 1st Team 2007 |
| Barron, Kelsie | Softball 1st Team 2009 |
| Bauman, Mariann | Softball 1st Team 1993; Softball 1st Team 1994 |
| Bauman, Noah | Football 1st Team 2019 2020, 2021 |
| Beauregard, Ryan | Track 4th Place Discus 2010 |
| Beck, Josh | Baseball 1st Team 2015; Baseball 1st Team 2016 |
| Berns-Moore, Karsyn | Softball 1st Team 2018; Softball 1st Team 2019 |
| Bertz, Herbie | Football 2nd Team 2016 |
| Bertz, Zack | Football 2nd Team 2017 |
| Bierley, Brian | Baseball 1st Team 1989 |
| Billau, Ambrelle | Softball, 1st Team 2021; 1st Team 2022 |
| Billau, Josh | Baseball 2nd Team 1999 |
| Billau, Justin | Baseball 2nd Team 1996; Baseball 1st Team, 1997 |
| Bischoff, Austin | Baseball 2nd Team 2011 |
| Bitz, Molly | Track 4th Place Two-Mile 1975; Track State Champion Two-Mile 1976, 7th Place 2-Mile, 1977 |
| Bixler, Lindsey | Track 8th Place 3200 2004 |
| Brighton, Chelsea | Volleyball 3rd Team 2007 |
| Bunge, Janie | Volleyball 2nd Team 2014 |
| Butz, Charlie | Football 1st Team 1994 |
| Butz, Robert | At-Large Selection Selection 2010 |
| Carter, Gary | Basketball 2nd Team 1983 |
| Chany, Breanne | Softball 1st Team 2000 |
| Clark, Sandy | Volleyball Coach of the Year 1985 |
| Clark-Gilmore, Bradyn | Football 1st Team 2018 |
| Cowell, Rachel | Softball 1st Team 1994 |
| Crigger, Shannon | Track 5th Place 1600 1997 |
| Crots, Ken | At-Large Selection 2014 |
| Crozier, Joel | Baseball 2nd Team 2012 |
| DeBarr, Hunter | Football 1st Team 2022, 2023 |
| DeLand, LeAnn | Softball 1st Team 2000 |
| DeShaun Williams | Football 1st Team 2018 |
| DiTerlizzi, Dominic | Baseball 1st Team 2001 |
| Draper, Steve | Baseball 2nd Team 1994 |
| DuPree, Chris | Track 5th Place 100 1988; Track 6th Place 200 1988; Track 2nd Place 100 1989; Track 2nd Place 200 1989 |
| DuPree, Everett | At-Large Selection 2017 |
| DuPree, Jake | At-Large Selection 2020 |
| DuPree, Josh | Track 7th Place 400, 2006; Track 2nd place High Jump 2006; Track 2nd Place 400 2006; Track 2nd Place 200 2007; Track State Champion 100 2008; Track State Champion 400 2008; Track 2nd Place 200 2008; Football 1st Team 2007; Basketball 1st Team 2008 |
| DuPree, Tony | At-Large Selection 2020 |
| Dusseau, Adam | Cross Country 3rd Place 1991; Track 2nd Place 1600; Track State Champion 3200 1992 |
| Eitniear, Thomas | Football 1st Team 2015; Baseball 2nd Team 2016; Football 1st Team 2017; Baseball 1st Team 2018 |
| Farrell, Shana | Track 6th Place 400 1997 |
| Fisher, Rob | Baseball 1st Team 2010 |
| Flanner, George | Track 5th Place Discus 2005; 8th Place Shot Put 2005; Track State Champion Discus 2007; Track State Champion Shot Put 2007; Football 1st Team 2006 |
| Flanner, Neil | Track 4th Place 3200 2003; Track 5th Place 1600 2003 |
| Funchion, Bryce | Baseball 1st Team 2007 |
| Funchion, Kaleigh | Softball 1st Team 2015 |
| Futrell, Emmett | Football 1st Team 1959 |
| Futrell, Terry | At-Large Selection 2010 |
| Gapp, Annabelle | Track 5th 300 Hurdles 2021 |
| Gaverick, Joe | Wrestling 2nd Place 1976 |
| Giesige, Cole | Baseball 2nd Team 2021, Football 1st Team 2021 |
| Granata, Alyssa | Softball 1st Team 2017 |
| Granata, Caitlin | Softball 1st Team 2010 |
| Gray, Kelvin | Baseball 2nd Team 1999 |
| Green, Lynette | Volleyball 3rd Team 1984 |
| Gust, Joe | Baseball 2nd Team 2002; Baseball 2nd Team 2003 |
| Hammons, Leigh Ann | Softball 1st Team 1993, Softball 1st Team 1994 |
| Hansen, Bill | Baseball 2nd Team 2009 |
| Hardin, Todd | Track 4th Place 400 1980 |
| Hauser, Elizabeth | Track 6th Place High Jump 2008, 8th Place High Jump 2007 |
| Hill, Nick | Baseball 1st Team 2001 |
| Hillard, Levi | Baseball, 2nd Team 2021 |
| Hubbard, Karen | Basketball 2nd Team 1978; Basketball 1st Team 1979 |
| Hubbard, Kathy | Track 7th Place Discuss, 1976 |
| Hubbard, Kris | Basketball Coach of the Year 1984 |
| Hughes, Justin | Baseball 2nd Team 2012 |
| Hughes, Matt | Baseball 2nd Team 1991 |
| Iott Jake | Football 1st Team 2022, 1st Team 2023; Track 8th 400 2023 |
| Iott, Jack | Football 1st Team 2023 |
| Iott, Joe | Football 1st Team 1992 |
| Iott, John | Football 1st Team 1989 |
| Iott, Milly | Softball 1st Team 2019 |
| Iott, Pat | At-Large Selection 2010 |
| Iott, Rhonda | Softball 1st Team 1987 |
| Johnson, Miranda | Track 3rd Place Long Jump 2011; Track 4th Place 200 2011; Track State Champion Long Jump 2012; Track 4th Place 100 2012; Track State Champion Long Jump 2013; Track 2nd Place 100 2013; Track State Champion 200 2013; Track State Champion Long Jump 2014; Track 2nd Place 100 2014; Track State Champion 200 2014 |
| Jones, Barry | Basketball 1st Team 1989 |
| Kahsen, Ken | Baseball 2nd Team 1996 |
| Keeling, Chelsea | Track 4th Place 100 2005; Track 4th Place 400 2005; Track 4th Place 200 2005 |
| Keller, Berlynn | Softball 1st Team 2021, Softball 1st Team 2022 |
| Keller, Dan | At-Large Selection 2010 |
| Kellerbaurer, Aaron | Football 2nd Team 2011 |
| Kiefer, Jesse | Football 1st Team 2015; Football 1st Team 2016 |
| Kiefer, Jodi | Softball 2nd Team 1987 |
| Knaggs, Drew | Football 1st Team 2023 |
| Knaggs, Tina | Softball 2nd Team 1984 |
| Knaggs, Traci | Volleyball 1st Team 1982; Softball 2nd Team 1982 |
| Koppelman, Dee | Basketball 1st Team 1990; Softball 2nd Team 1989; Softball 1st Team 1990, Softball 1st Team 1991 |
| Koppelman, Leslie | Volleyball 2nd Team 1994 |
| Koppelman, Rae | Volleyball 2nd Team 1997; Volleyball 1st Team 1998; Softball 1st Team 1998 |
| Koppelman, Rich | At-Large Selection 2010 |
| Kramer, Micah | Football 1st Team 1995 |
| Kremnetz, Randy | Track 5th Place Shot Put 1966 |
| Kubitz, Ron | Football 1st Team 1964 |
| Kutzke, Alisa | Softball 2nd Team 1985 |
| Kutzke, Fred | Baseball 1st Team 1995; Football 1st Team 1993; Football 1st Team 1994 |
| Lake, Colin | Basketball 1st Team 2012; Basketball 1st Team 2013; Basketball 1st Team 2014 |
| Lake, Hunter | Football 2nd Team 2017; 1st Team 2018 |
| Langenderfer, Pam | Softball 1st Team 1992 |
| LaRocca, Jami | Track Coach of the Year 2007 |
| LaRoy, Gabe | Baseball 2nd Team 2013 |
| Leathers, Sara | Softball 2nd Team 1984 |
| Lee, Chase | Football 1st Team 2024 |
| Lenhart, Connor | Golf 1st Team 2016; Golf 1st Team 2017; Golf 1st Team 2018 |
| Long, Alexa | Track 7th Place Discus, 2012 |
| Long, Lorie | Volleyball 1st Team 1977; Track 5th Place Shot Put 1977 |
| Long, Sandy | Softball 1st Team 1984; Softball 1st Team 1985; Basketball 2nd Team 1984 |
| Luck, Mike | Football 1st Team 1971 |
| Luettke, Jack | Baseball Coach of the Year 1991 |
| Luse, Brayden | Football 1st Team 2022 |
| Lykowski, Liz | At-Large Selection 2010 |
| Manley, Erin | Softball 1st Team 2016; Softball 1st Team 2017 |
| Marckel, Karen | Track 8th Place 200 1977 |
| Martin, Brandon | Track 8th Place Long Jump 2003 |
| Masserant, Kolby | Football 1st Team 2023 |
| Masters, Keegan | Cross Country 2022, Track 6th 1600 2023 |
| Mensing, Jason | Football Coach of the Year 2017 |
| Minsel, Holly | Track State Champion 3200 1991 |
| Miracola, Anthony | Basketball 1st Team 2003 |
| Murphy, Dawn | Basketball 1st Team 1988; Basketball 1st Team 1989; Softball 2nd Team 1989; Softball 1st Team 1990 |
| Murphy, Logan | Football 1st Team 2017; Football 1st Team 2018 |
| Nelson, Unity | Softball 1st Team 2021, Softball 1st Team 2022, Softball 1st Team 2023 |
| Nieman, Brad | Basketball 1st Team 1988 |
| Ondrovick, Bob | Football, MHSFCA Hall of Fame Inductee 2022 |
| Osnowitz, Ed | At-Large Selection 2015 |
| Ovall, Chris | Football 1st Team 2000 |
| Ovall, Corey | Track 3rd Place Discus 2004 |
| Ovall, Dan | Track 3rd Place Discus 2007 |
| Overman, Olivia | Track 6th Place Discus 2013 |
| Pant, Travis | Baseball 1st Team 2009 |
| Perry, Doug | Baseball 1st Team 1989 |
| Plumer, Bobby | Golf Top 10 2002 |
| Puse, Keagen | Track 2nd Place 300 Hurdles 2004; Track 4th Place 100 Hurdles 2005; Track State Champion 300 Hurdles 2005; Track 3rd Place 110 Hurdles 2006; Track 2nd Place 300 Hurdles 2006 |
| Relay team | 400 Relay 3rd Place 1988; 800 Relay 3rd Place 1988 (Chris DuPree, Troy Goetz, Bryan Pfaff, Matt Waterford); |
| Relay team | 800 Relay 8th Place 2003 (Vince LaRocca, Brandon Martin, Bobby Plumer, Matt Ringle) |
| Relay Team | 3200 Relay 8th Place 2005 (Lisa Dumkow, Elizabeth Hauser, Jackie DeBruyne, Ashley Klima) |
| Relay team | 800 Relay 2nd Place 2005 (Josh DuPree, Anthony LaRocca, Keagen Puse, Nate Seevers) |
| Relay team | 400 Relay 2nd Place 2006 (Aaron Flanner, Keagen Puse, Nate Seevers, Josh DuPree) |
| Relay team | 400 Relay 2nd Place 2007 (Josh DuPree, George Flanner, Dan Ovall, Nate Seevers) |
| Relay team | 800 Relay 3rd Place 2007 (Josh DuPree, Brandon Iott, Dan Ovall, Nate Seevers) |
| Relay team | 1600 Relay 5th Place 2008 (Aaron Flanner, Ryan Klima, David Lindsay, Josh DuPree) |
| Relay team | 400 Relay 3rd Place 2021 (Paige Thomas, Madelyn Thomas, Aubrie Simmons, Annie Gapp) |
| Relay team | 1600 Relay 8th Place 2022 (Dylan Anderson, Ty Rddy, Ryan Oberle, Jake Iott) |
| Relay Team | 1600 Relay State Champion 2023 (Shea Ruddy, Dylan Anderson, Ryin Ruddy, Jake Iott) |
| Relay Team | 400 Relay 5th Place 2023 (Stepan Masserant, Kolby Masserant, Ryin Ruddy, Shea Ruddy) |
| Relay Team | 800 Relay 8th Place 2023 (Cooper Bieber, Dylan Anderson, Ryin Ruddy, Jake Iott) |
| Rice, John | Basketball Coach of the Year 1982 |
| Ritzenthaler, Emily | Softball 1st Team 2014 |
| Ritzenthaler, Jake | Baseball 2nd Team 2008; Baseball 2nd Team 2009 |
| Roberts, Joe | Baseball 2nd Team 2002 |
| Ross, Leigh | Basketball 1st Team 1986; Basketball 1st Team 1987; Softball 2nd Team 1985; Softball 1st Team 1987 |
| Ruddy, Ryin | Football 1st Team 2022, Football 1st Team 2023, Track 8th Hurdles 2023 |
| Ruddy, Shea | Football, 1st Team 2021, Football 1st Team 2022, Track 2nd 400 2023 |
| Russell, Dick | Football 2nd Team 1964 |
| Schmidt, Holly | Softball 1st Team 1982 |
| Schmidt, Peg | Softball 1st Team 1990 |
| Seevers, Nate | Track 6th Place Long Jump 2007 |
| Seigneur, Daryl | Golf Top 10 1976 |
| Sharpe, Eddie | Basketball 1st Team 1997; Basketball 1st Team 1998 |
| Shepherd, Alan | Track 7th Place 800 2004 |
| Sieler, Tim | Wrestling State Champion 1982 |
| Sims, Chris | Football 1st Team 2012 |
| Smith, Shelley | Softball 1st Team 1990; Softball 1st Team 1991 |
| Smith, Todd | Baseball 1st Team 1991 |
| Stark, Jeff | Track 2nd Place Pole Vault 1977 |
| Stark, Robert | Football 2nd Team 1961 |
| Steffen, Mike | Football 2nd Team 1972 |
| Stevens, Nate | Baseball 2nd team 2024 |
| Strahan, Brad | Basketball 1st Team 1994 |
| Sturdevant, Richard | Football 1st Team 1985, Wrestling 2nd Place 1986 |
| Suchora, Shane | Football 1st Team 2022 |
| Swaney, Chris | Track 4th Place Discus 1996; Track 4th Place Discus 1998 |
| Tammerine, Logan | Baseball 2nd Team 2021, Baseball 2nd Team 2022, Baseball 1st Team 2023 |
| Taylor, Matthew | Football 1st Team 2017 |
| Tesznar, Lucas | Football 1st Team 2016, Football 1st Team 2017 |
| Thieken, Todd | Football 1st Team 2022 |
| Thomas, Paige | Track 3rd 400 2021; Track 4th 100 2021; Track 5th 200 2021 |
| Toda, Andrew | Baseball 1st Team 2018 |
| Tomes, Diane | Track State Champion 880 1975 |
| Tomes, Sonya | Track 5th Place Mile 1975; Track 2nd Place Mile 1976 |
| Trabbic, Cindy | Softball 1st Team 1990 |
| Track, Grant | Baseball 2nd Team 2011 |
| VanBrandt, Aly | Softball 1st Team 2021, Softball 1st Team 2022, Softball 1st Team 2023 |
| VanBrandt, Jamie | Softball 1st Team 1986, Softball 2nd Team 1987, Softball 2nd Team 1988 |
| VanBrandt, Matt | Baseball 1st Team 1992 |
| Viers, Jacki | Softball 2nd Team 1985 |
| Walker, Lindsey | Softball 1st Team 2017; Softball 1st Team 2018; Softball 1st Team 2019 |
| Wallace, Pam | Volleyball 1st Team 1977 |
| Warner, Gary | At-Large Selection 2010 |
| Waterford, Seamus | Football 1st Team 2022 |
| Welly, Jim | Track 6th Place Shot Put 1986; Track 5th Place 200 1986; Wrestling 2nd Place 1986 |
| Welly, Paul | Wrestling State Champion 1982 |
| White, Paige | Volleyball 2nd Team 2011 |
| Wingate, Phill | Track 8th Place High Hurdles 2010 |
| Wohlfarth, Nick | Football 1st Team 2002 |
| Yingling, Kerry | Track 5th Place High Jump 1990 |
